Of Monsters and Madness
Author: Jessica Verday
Publication Date: September 9th 2014
Publisher: EgmontUSA
~A copy was provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review~
A romantic, historical retelling of classic Gothic horror featuring Edgar Allan Poe and his character Annabel Lee, from a New York Times best-selling author.Summoned to her father's home in 1820's Philadelphia, a girl finds herself in the midst of a rash of gruesome murders in which he might be implicated. She is torn romantically between her father's assistants-one kind and proper, one mysterious and brooding-who share a dark secret and may have more to do with the violent events than they're letting on.
I'm not going to pretend I know anything about the poem of
Annabel Lee. I know it, of course, but I've never studied it, and although I do
like poetry, it's not exactly my favourite thing in the world. I've seen Mary
Lindsey's Ashes on Waves that made me want to read it, so when I saw Of
Monsters and Madness I couldn't resist (I mean, have you read that title? Of.
Monsters. and. Madness. It practically screams read me!) Besides, In the land of Gods and Monsters...I had
Lana Del Rey's Gods & Monsters in my head the whole time (don't ask why, my
brain doesn't know. And we're not talking about my love for Lana Del Rey, we're
talking about the book, right? No more music talk.)
While it's a short and quick read, I read the whole thing in
two hours, so it sounds like I really liked it to read it so quick, right?
Wrong. Don't get me wrong it lives up to its name. It's a little crazy and
vividly disgusting in some places, and it's definitely madness, but the
in-between those lovely chapters, the
filler chapters bored me. I read it so quick because those crazy
chapters kept me reading and I wanted it done otherwise I would've been
dragging myself along for days with it otherwise.
Of Monsters and Madness starts with a Wrong Turn preface, and then the official story starts as Annabel
Lee comes to live with her Father after an invitation for her and her Mother to
stay, but Annabel Lee is the only one who arrives. She meets her Father's
servants and the mysterious Mr. Poe after he saves her from drowning. She
quickly makes friends with Maddy, and though she's her servant, Annabel Lee is
used to doing things her own way and isn't accustomed to people doing things
for her. For what she hoped to spend time to get to know and have a father, but
is quickly disheartened when her Father is outwardly disapproving of her and
she hardly gets to see him since he's in his workspace for most of the time,
doing God knows what. And that's what Annabel Lee wants to find out. By her
curiosity she meet's the disarming Edgar, Mr. Allan Poe's cousin, and her Father's assistant, and as her curiosity
grows and a murderer is on the loose, the truth is nothing she could ever dream
of.
The house is luxurious and vivid, it's written beautifully
and atmospheric. The writing wasn't a problem for me, however the characters
were, I just couldn't connect to them. I like them alright, but they didn't
feel like anything special. There's not much going on either, and the twists
and plot are predictable, it's shame really because it had so much potential. And
I'm going to that synopsis. Romantic? Are you kidding me? 1) The romance wasn't
even that good and 2) it was fucking creepy and twisted. It was not romantic.
Also, working in Edgar Allen Poe as a character is so wrong in so many ways. Then
there's the note in the back, where it says while researching the author had to
take liberties with the timeline. There's taking liberties and then there's taking liberties. It's a thin line that
in all honestly, was crossed with Of Monsters of Madness.
Of Monsters and Madness is like a sum, If you add a story
behind Annabel Lee and Jekyl & Hyde it would make this baby.
Rating: 2/5
This book kind of sounds like 'The Dark Unwinding' by Sharon Cameron, but based on your review it's so much worse. It's actually disappointing because the synopsis actually made it sound interesting. However, if there are two things I hate, they are bad romances and filler chapters, so I really don't think I'll go anywhere near this book.
ReplyDeleteHa, I'll have to check out The Dark Unwinding now...and just did! I actually know that one, (haven't read it though.)
Deletewell that's disappointing.. I actually just saw this in goodreads and the title really caught my attention.. I like how it seems to be vividly written but it turns out to be disappointing as I read how you talked about the characters, the predictability of the story, the filler chapters, and the romance (I can't believe this has a romance).. ohwell, thanks for the honest review :)
ReplyDeleteczai @ the Blacksheep Project
Right? I had high hopes for it, shame. :(
DeleteI'm sorry it wasn't that good even if finally it was a fast read. I didn't know about this one but poetry isn't thatmuch for me either I confess. And I can understand the other points as well...
ReplyDeleteIf it wasn't short, I probably wouldn't have finished it, ha.
DeleteThe title and cover is awesome! Too bad that the book isn't as awesome as it's title. The "romance" sounds pretty horrible from the summary, but in the typical YA fashion, it makes me wonder what it is in the book to provoke such a reaction from you. I guess I'll never know. I really don't plan on reading this one.
ReplyDeleteYup. :( I never thought I'd have a problem with taking a figure as a character, it's been done before and it hasn't annoyed me, but this one just did. Probably because it just didn't work. And the authors note. Taking liberty with the timeline- especially his timeline, makes it based in fiction.
DeleteDoes sound very creepy and probably not my kind of book. Glad you found a few things to like though
ReplyDeleteNot a lot though. :(
DeleteIs that not the creepiest cover ever?
ReplyDeleteYup, what made me want to read it. :(
DeleteNow I need to listen to some Lana. I love that song!! I think I'll skip the book and listen to some music instead. lol
ReplyDeleteHaha, yeah, do. ;)
DeleteI hate when I can't connect to the characters. If I can't connect to them, how am I supposed to empathize for them? How am I supposed to be engaged by the story if I don't care about the characters in the story? I hate predictable plots and twists. It's not a twist if we can guess! Bad romance too?? Yikes. Great review, Kirsty!
ReplyDeleteRachel @ A Perfection Called Books
Exactly! Yeah, I'm really hating obvious ones right now, they're just boring me lately.
Delete