Monday, 13 April 2015

Review: The Secrets We Keep







The Secrets We Keep
Author:
Publication Date: April 28th 2015
Publisher: Farrar, Straus and Giroux (BYR)
~A copy was provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review~

A girl takes over her twin sister's identity in this emotionally charged page-turner about the complicated bond between sisters.

Ella and Maddy Lawton are identical twins. Ella has spent her high school years living in popular Maddy's shadows, but she has never been envious of Maddy. In fact, she's chosen the quiet, safe confines of her sketchbook over the constant battle for attention that has defined Maddy's world.

When—after a heated argument—Maddy and Ella get into a tragic accident that leaves her sister dead, Ella wakes up in the hospital surrounded by loved ones who believe she is Maddy. Feeling responsible for Maddy's death and everyone's grief, Ella makes a split-second decision to pretend to be Maddy. Soon, Ella realizes that Maddy's life was full of secrets. Caught in a web of lies, Ella is faced with two options—confess her deception or live her sister's life

The Secrets We Keep is a hard one to review, because whether you agree with Ella's decision or not, you will never know what you would do in her situation, unless you have a twin. It's bad enough losing a sister or brother, but a twin, that's the other half of you? That's a whole different bond only twins have, especially identical twins. It is character driven, and because of that I'm not quite sure how I feel about it.

When Maddy and Ella were younger, they were inseparable and as close as you expect twins to be, until Maddy drastically changes after falling in with the 'in' crowd in high school and started dating Alex. The way she acted, the way she did her hair and makeup, to everything she wore changed to appease the people around her. Maddy shut off the way she used to be, and effectively, shutting out Ella. 

 As I said, I don't quite know how to feel about The Secrets We Keep, I know I liked it, but...Here's the thing, I didn't like most of the characters. Frankly, Maddy is a bitch. Being dead doesn't change that. Maybe that was Alex's affect on her, but it never excused what she did, whether she was sorry or not. I despised Alex,  he's controlling and an Idealist, basically, the guy is abusive. Which, you get to see that side of him once Ella takes over. Everything had to be right, Maddy had to do and say whatever he said, at one point he even told her to be quiet. The rest of the 'friends' and side characters are just as bad, and I use the term 'friends' loosely, sine they'll shove a knife in your back if you turn your back on them.

Ella and Josh were the only ones I liked, and I didn't like them all the time, either. Ella is...complicated. There's no other way to perceive her, and with what happened, what do you expect? She wonders what is wrong with her, with Maddy shutting her out, and everything's Maddy 24/7, she feels like she doesn't exist to anyone-even her parents- but Josh. Ella's decision to take over Maddy's life isn't out of jealous but out of grief and regret, she honestly thought that it was the best thing to do for everyone, since she thinks her parents loved Maddy more than her. Josh is my kind of guy, artistic, loyal, the only thing that irked me with him is how he kind of pitted Ella and Kim against one another.

As emotional as it was, there's a drawback because I never felt connected to the characters, but it was sad to see Ella go through all the things she was, she wasn't grieving for her sister because she was trying to keep her alive, and she wasn't grieving for the her she lost for the same reason. It was interesting to see her how she became Maddy day in and day out and nobody questioned that she might not be Maddy.

The Secrets We Keep is very character driven, the characters aren't perfect, but they are realistic in that way, but mainly The Secrets We Keep is centred around family dynamics and the bond of twins, how it can stretch and tear and the way of losing that bond can feel like losing a part of yourself.


Rating: 4/5



     


 

Comments (23)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
LoL I sometimes like bitch characters but I don't think I would like Maddy one bit!

I'm surprised that these characters came across as realistic. I find it the most difficult to find characters that are relatable in mysteries, they usually play into stereotypes.

Lovely review Kristy! I'm gonna see if this is at my library come May!
My recent post Weekly Wrap Up: April 6, 2015-April 11,2015
1 reply · active 527 weeks ago
She isn't really in it that long (well, the real Maddy, anyway), she's talked about a lot though, and we do get to see the good and bad Maddy through Ella.

I don't think Maddy's friends did (at least, that was totally not my high school experience) but Ella was. :)
I like character driven stories. While you seem to not like many characters, I'm still very interested to read it because of the way you talk about Ella. And maybe it was really the author's intention to make you dislike those characters. Great review, Kristy! :) Now I'm more excited to get my hands on this one.

My recent post [REVIEW] As the Crow Flies
1 reply · active 527 weeks ago
I hope it was, you know, because they didn't seem that realistic to me, because they were...well, not. Haha, that was not my high school experience anyway.
This is one of my most anticipated reads. For whatever reason, I love anything to do with twins or sibling relationships, so this sounds right up my alley. And I absolutely love character driven stories too - especially if the characters are complex and relatable. Even though these characters don't sound perfect (in hindsight. who of us are?) they sound realistic and well-developed. Thanks for sharing Kristy - I didn't think it was possible, but you've made me even more excited for this one! ;)
My recent post Under a Painted Sky
1 reply · active 527 weeks ago
Me too! It's the twin dynamics, so fun (well, when it's in a less serious book like this) and exactly, we're not, and it just makes (well, the good ones) them feel flawed and real. :)
It's great that even if you didn't like most of the characters you had a great time with the story. I confess that I don't have a twin so it's difficult to know what to do in her situation but that's what is interesting as well. thanks for the review!
1 reply · active 527 weeks ago
Exactly, so I couldn't really not like her because of that, you know? So she definitely was complex but flawed and real. :)
so maybe I would have the "i want to slap you" connection with the characters too. I really want to read this book and I think its a lot of the same feels for you as Dissappearing girls were for me. Just a bunch of messed up characters but a very emotional story.
I need to get to this one soon.
My recent post Review: Vanishing Girls by Lauren Oliver
2 replies · active 527 weeks ago
Lol I meant Vanishing girls. same thing right.
My recent post Review: Vanishing Girls by Lauren Oliver
I still need to read Vanishing Girls, but exactly, complex but real characters make the best emotional stories. :)
I really want to read this book because there are so many books about twins but I've never seen anything like this one! I like books with strong, likeable characters and it's interesting the way you talked about Ella.
1 reply · active 527 weeks ago
I've only read a few with and about twins, but it is so fun (well, in less serious story as this). At times Ella was a bit...much, and I wanted to shake her a few times, mainly to do with why she kept pretending she was Maddy, but still, such a good story. :)
This book was so, so good. I think it was very unique because of the twin thing, and I mean, it was all so complicated (in a good way!) because of it. I agree with the characters not always being likable (or like Alex, never being likable- I hate him) but they were realistically flawed, so it worked, and I couldn't help but be so heartbroken for Ella. It was a very moving story, for sure!
My recent post Most Excellent Excerpts
1 reply · active 527 weeks ago
See, you definitely couldn't sum up the book in one word, because it is just so many things and about so many different things at the same time. I didn't understand why she switched, to a degree, but so felt for her. :(
I totally understood and hated her decision all the time and wondered how long she could keep it up
My recent post Review: Things We Know by Heart by Jessi Kirby
1 reply · active 527 weeks ago
The more I think about it, the more I do get it, and I don't get how she kept it up as long as she did, because she was really punishing herself for something that wasn't her fault. :(
This book seems so deep, but honestly I am a bit aprehensive about it. Because I'm not a big fan of books with this kind of plots. But I'm glad you enjoyed this Kirsty!
1 reply · active 527 weeks ago
It is a sad and emotional one, so I wouldn't read it unless you were in the mood for that type of book, so good though! :)
YES to your review <3 This cover is very beautiful - I rated the novel the same as you :) I agree, that it's more of a character driven novel than a plot driven which I really liked - the plot was pretty good as well, although Ella was a bit absurd to make that impulsive decision, I did like how the ending turned out though. Lovely review overall x
My recent post ARC Review: All The Rage by Courtney Summers + Giveaway[U.S/CAN]!
1 reply · active 527 weeks ago
The cover sums up the story well, simple yet complex and beautiful. :) I think that's why it worked so well as it did, because if it wasn't more character driven, wouldn't have been as moving as it was. :)
You make a great point about how we shouldn't judge anyone's decisions - simply because we aren't them and can't really understand. Love your review! I think I will read this one eventually, I am curious about the characters.
My recent post Review: The Jewel by Amy Ewing
1 reply · active 527 weeks ago
Thank you! But exactly, just because I didn't understand her decision, doesn't mean you can't feel for her, can't imagine ever having to make that call, horrible. :(

Post a new comment

Comments by