Thursday, 2 April 2015

Guest Review by Amber: Old Magic



Old Magic 
Author:
December 7th 2009 
Bloomsbury Publishing PLC

Pages : 317
Rough estimate of time it took to read : 18 hours
Source: Gifted by Kirsty



* Just a little note



Before I get to the review, I just wanted to add a little message,  this is my first ever book review and  My wonderful cousin, Kirsty (she didn't tell me to say that *cough*)  has lent me some of her books that she couldn't finish,  


Since this is my first review it will only be a short, as I'm still new to this whole scene of things and need some practice.  Although Kirsty and I share some taste in books (e.g. Harry Potter, some of the Vampire genre and some of the classics), I will be reviewing my own (and my romantic partner's), so we'll have a few different genres within MG, YA and Adult. 


So some reviews you get off me will be slightly different than others as its all down to the books and how well or easy I find them to read. (Which will be difficult for me as I suffer from mild Dyslexia, which makes me read slower, but I love to read so will try my best to make my reviews readable with Kirsty's, help of course.)


Thoughts


I found this book very easy to read although I noticed (even with my own brain rebelling against me and trying to make me think otherwise) that there are some word/sentence glitches, for example on page 45, second row down from the top there's a line that makes me think 'What? Shouldn't it be ____ instead'. The line also made me lose concentration and kept me from connecting back into the story for a while after. 

There are three sections to Old Magic, and I found that during the first (the longest) section felt drawn out and unnecessary, more like filler chapters that helped the story along instead of adding to the story. Once I slugged through the filter and got to the good parts, it got a lot better and I enjoyed it a long more. The last part of the book felt rushed, especially the ending and of course we have a cliffhanger, but a cliffhanger that did make me want to read the next in the series. Until I realized there wasn't another. 

I enjoyed the romantic duo of the main characters and the sequence of how things panned out so they were "forced" into such an interesting scene where there romantic sides could somewhat show. I also enjoyed how both main characters were portrayed and were their own person (although as mentioned near the end things seemed  rushed and so I felt like the characters kind of merged together in a way that confused my mind as to what chapter was who.) I would like to read more as I feel that the story is unfinished but I would recommend this book to a friend if they wanted a short story they could sit and enjoy for a couple hours. 








Comments (9)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
This one is totally new to me and It looks good. I love finding new books from blogs. :) I like that you put the time it took you to read

Great Review!

Michelle @ Book Briefs
1 reply · active 521 weeks ago
PoemMistress123's avatar

PoemMistress123 · 521 weeks ago

i like taking down how long it took for me to read, as if it doesnt take me long to read you'll know i enjoyed the book as i couldnt stick it down.
:)
I remember reading this! Kind of xD Most of the details are gone from my mind but I do remember struggling with it in the beginning same as you did until it picked up. Nice review :)
My recent post ARC Review: Magonia by Maria Dahvana Headley
1 reply · active 521 weeks ago
PoemMistress123's avatar

PoemMistress123 · 521 weeks ago

thank you for the comment
im glad i wasnt the only one that struggled
Great job! I'm not sure this is the right book for me, but that's good you liked aspects of it. From your review, it sounds like the middle section is the best. Sorry there isn't a second book to continue with! Maybe there will be in the future?

-lauren
My recent post When You Leave by Monica Ropal + Make it a Gift
1 reply · active 521 weeks ago
PoemMistress123's avatar

PoemMistress123 · 521 weeks ago

this may not be the right book for you but theres many more reviews to come so hopefully you'll find a review and think the book may be good to read :D
i hope theres a 2nd book too
Hmm. I don't think I have heard of this one! I mean, on one hand, it DOES sound interesting, and the fact that you were pulled in AND wanted to read more is great. But... if there isn't more AND it ends on a cliffhanger, well, that just seems mean! Very nice review :)
My recent post Review: Magonia by Maria Dahvana Headley
PoemMistress123's avatar

PoemMistress123 · 521 weeks ago

finding out there wasnt another boook really did sadden me, but on the bright side it appeals to the writer side of me to make my own 2nd book for the story so maybe there will be a 2nd book in the future :D
As I was scrolling down Bloglovin' I came across this review and had to do a double take. Old Magic is one of the original books that got me really involved in reading!! I absolutely loved it and have read it probably 20 times, granted I haven't read it in recent years so my opinion of how amazing it is could change (back then I didn't get too worked up over bad writing). I'm just so glad to come across someone else who has read it!

Post a new comment

Comments by